Patent owner’s attempt to escape a fee award by suing in a different district court goes nowhere

TRAXCELL TECHNOLOGIES, LLC v. CELLCO PARTNERSHIP

Authored by: Jeremy J. Gustrowsky

The Federal Circuit has shut down an unusual effort to erase an attorneys’ fee award by filing a brand-new lawsuit in a different federal district court. The court held that while it had appellate jurisdiction over the appeal, the district court that heard the new case never had jurisdiction to begin with, and it ordered the case dismissed.

The dispute traces back to 2017, when Traxcell Technologies, LLC sued Verizon in the Eastern District of Texas over U.S. Patent Nos. 8,977,284, 9,510,320, 9,642,024, and 9,549,388. The district court found some claims indefinite and granted summary judgment of noninfringement on the rest. The Federal Circuit affirmed that ruling in 2021. The district court then awarded Verizon attorneys’ fees under 35 U.S.C. § 285, the statute allowing fee awards in “exceptional” cases, and the Federal Circuit affirmed that award too in a short Rule 36 judgment. The Supreme Court declined to take the case.

Traxcell then tried a new theory it had never raised before, arguing that once the Federal Circuit issued its mandate affirming the merits judgment, the Eastern District of Texas no longer had jurisdiction to award fees. Traxcell filed an emergency motion raising that argument in the Eastern District (still pending) and, at the same time, filed a separate lawsuit in the Western District of Texas. That second suit was styled as an “independent action,” an old equitable remedy preserved by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(d)(1) that allows a party to seek relief from a judgment. The Western District denied Traxcell’s request for a preliminary injunction against enforcement of the fee award, and the parties stipulated to a final judgment so Traxcell could appeal.

On appeal, Verizon argued the Federal Circuit lacked jurisdiction because the case turned only on the mandate rule, not on patent law. The court disagreed. Because the lawsuit was an attempt to set aside a judgment entered under § 285, a provision of the Patent Act, it functioned much like a declaratory judgment action seeking a ruling of no liability for fees. That placed the appeal within the Federal Circuit’s jurisdiction over cases arising under the patent laws.

Having confirmed its own jurisdiction, the court turned to the district court’s and found it lacking for two independent reasons. First, independent actions under Rule 60(d)(1) are reserved for extraordinary situations, available only to prevent what the Supreme Court has called a “grave miscarriage of justice.” Traxcell’s briefing never even mentioned that standard, and the court described the underlying theory as frivolous. Trial courts routinely decide fee motions after a merits judgment has been affirmed on appeal, and the Federal Circuit regularly reviews those later fee rulings. The court also noted that Traxcell could have raised its jurisdictional argument during the earlier fee appeal and did not, which barred it from reopening the issue through a collateral attack.

Second, and more broadly, the court held that one district court simply cannot entertain an independent action to undo another district court’s judgment that an appellate court has already affirmed. Drawing on decisions from the D.C. Circuit and the Fifth Circuit, the panel emphasized that Rule 60 does not confer “super-appellate jurisdiction” on district courts. Allowing the Western District to void a judgment the Federal Circuit had affirmed would effectively let a trial court overrule an appeals court.

The practical lesson for litigants is straightforward. Jurisdictional objections to a fee award need to be raised in the case where the fees were sought and, if necessary, on direct appeal. Filing a fresh suit in a more convenient district after losing (and after the Supreme Court declines review) is not a viable second chance. The Federal Circuit vacated the Western District’s judgment, remanded with instructions to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction, and awarded costs to Verizon.