Authored by: Jeremy J. Gustrowsky
The Federal Circuit has affirmed two Patent Trial and Appeal Board decisions cancelling all claims of Netlist’s U.S. Patent Nos. 11,093,417 and 9,858,215, both titled “Memory Module with Data Buffering.” The Board had found the claims obvious over U.S. Patent No. 7,363,422 (the Perego patent) combined with JESD79-2, the DDR2 SDRAM specification published by JEDEC, the organization that writes industry standards for microelectronics. The appeal turned entirely on one question: whether a skilled engineer would have had a reason to put those two references together.
Some background helps. Computer memory modules are built to industry specifications that govern, among other things, how individual memory chips are selected and addressed. Under JEDEC standards, memory chips are grouped into “ranks” that are turned on or off by a “chip select” signal from the computer’s memory controller. Rambus, Inc. promoted a competing architecture that used no chip select signals at all, instead giving each chip a unique identifier so commands could be aimed at a specific device. Netlist’s patents claim a memory module that sits in the JEDEC world, using chip select signals plus buffering circuitry that isolates the memory ranks from the memory controller, along with a “CAS latency” timing adjustment to account for the delay the buffer introduces.
Netlist did not argue that the Perego and JEDEC references, taken together, failed to disclose every element of the claims. Its argument was that Perego was designed for Rambus architecture, and that bolting JEDEC chip select signals onto Perego would make Perego useless for Rambus and would also destroy Perego’s stated benefit of backward compatibility with earlier generations of memory devices. In Netlist’s view, no skilled artisan would knowingly break a reference in order to build the combination.
The Federal Circuit said this misreads obviousness law. Quoting the Supreme Court’s decision in KSR, the court reiterated that familiar items often have obvious uses beyond their original purposes and that skilled artisans can fit teachings from multiple patents together like puzzle pieces. The proper question is whether a skilled person would have been motivated to combine the references to arrive at the claimed invention, not whether the combination still satisfies requirements of the primary reference that the challenged claims never cared about. The court pointed to its 2023 Axonics decision, where a nerve electrode from the primary reference was repurposed for a different nerve, and it did not matter that the modified device could no longer serve the original target.
The court did map out the narrow situations where a prior art reference’s own purpose still matters. One is where the reference itself is the source of the asserted motivation to combine, as in the old In re Gordon case involving a gasoline filter that would not work if flipped upside down. The other is where the purpose that gets destroyed is a purpose shared with the challenged claims, as in Polaris (raising a vehicle’s center of gravity when a low center of gravity was the point of both the claims and the reference), Medtronic, and Chemours. Netlist’s case fit neither mold. Compatibility with Rambus and backward compatibility were Perego’s goals, not goals of Netlist’s claimed invention, and the challengers never leaned on Perego’s Rambus features to supply the motivation.
The court then found substantial evidence supporting the Board’s motivation findings. Perego itself described bussed topologies as an alternative to Rambus’s point to point links, disclosed a 64-bit data width that matched JEDEC modules and exceeded Rambus’s 36-bit maximum, and referenced row and column address strobe lines used in JEDEC systems. Perego also emphasized flexibility across “a variety of possible module configurations.” On top of that, Netlist’s own expert acknowledged that JEDEC-compliant modules dominated the market at the relevant time, which gave a designer ample reason to build toward the JEDEC standard. The court also rejected Netlist’s claim that the Board ignored its backward compatibility argument, noting that the Board quoted and discussed the exact passage of Perego at issue.
One procedural footnote is worth mentioning. Samsung settled with Netlist before oral argument and the Micron entities settled afterward, and the Patent and Trademark Office declined to step in. The Federal Circuit nonetheless resolved the appeal, because a live controversy over the patentability of the claims remained. The result is a clean reaffirmation that a patent owner cannot defeat an obviousness challenge simply by showing that the combination would wreck the prior art’s original application.