2020 June

Many times Businesses form and thrive because of a revolutionary product like the smart phone, or because of a new service model like ride sharing. These products and services often include novel processes for solving old problems, or new and useful combinations of existing products. Sometimes no one thought to try it, or perhaps for many years everyone believed it couldn’t be done. Common misconceptions about the patent system can result in missed opportunities to jump-start growth, secure market share, and give a superior business model the chance to dominate the marketplace in the face of strong competition. Following are some “gotchas” related to the patent process that result in missed opportunities.

If I Patent It, I Can Build It: Not necessarily. It is possible to make the product you claim in your patent, and still infringe someone else’s patent. That’s because patents do not grant you the right to make and sell your product or service. Patents only grant you the right to stop others from making or selling your product. For example, Kerri has a patent on a cup, and Joe patents an improvement on the cup by adding a handle. Now Kerri has a patent on cups and Joe has a patent on cups with handles. Before Joe can make and sell cups with handles, he must obtain Kerri’s permission because he cannot make a cup with a handle without first making a cup. Kerri’s patent gives her the right to stop anyone from making cups of any kind, with or without handles.

I’ll Sell It First, Then Patent It Later: The first impulse for many entrepreneurs is to see if the product has market acceptance before proceeding with a patent process that may cost precious startup capital. The U.S. patent system still provides a year to file for patent protection after the first disclosure or offer for sale, but the U.S. system is unique in this regard. Rights can be lost when details are mentioned in public and then left out of the patent application by mistake. Also, any public disclosure means you will not be able to pursue patent protection on the concept anywhere else in the world. While this may be less of a concern to some businesses, it can become a serious obstacle to growth as the business takes off in other countries. With a little careful planning before that first disclosure, entrepreneurs and inventors should establish a road map through the patent system that fits their budget and gives them the best chance of retaining patent rights now that may soon become very valuable.

I’ll Keep My Patent a Secret: The patent system gives inventors the exclusive right to stop others from making, using, or selling their patented invention. In return, inventors are required to teach the world how to make the invention. This way others can study the drawings and description in the issued patent to quickly learn from the inventor and make improvements on the concept sooner, rather than later and thereby advance the overall state of the art more efficiently. Conversely, inventors that try to obtain a patent without disclosing the most important aspects of the invention may cripple their opportunities for obtaining viable patent protection in the U.S. and abroad. Furthermore, this approach may also destroy options for securing IP rights that might otherwise be available such as trade secret protection. Here again, there are several ways to address this issue, all of which are ideally considered early on as part of a cohesive IP strategy – preferably long before valuable IP rights are potentially lost.

Entrepreneurs and small businesses owners – Register to attend a free webinar about the basics of copyright and receive insights into copyright registration and enforcement.

The 90-minute program is on Tuesday, June 16, from 1-2:30 p.m. ET.

Specifically designed for the needs of entrepreneurs and small businesses, the webinar will feature presentations by copyright experts from the USPTO’s Office of Policy and International Affairs. For more information and to register, visit: USPTO

The firm congratulates Quentin G. Cantrell on his 20th anniversary.

Known for his extensive brief writing and case strategy, Mr. Cantrell has represented clients in matters involving patent and trademark litigation.

We thank Mr. Cantrell for his service to clients and his many contributions to the firm’s success.